The Jam

All Your Eggs In One Basket

Has anyone ever told you not to keep all your eggs in one basket? We’re about to throw caution to the wind! We’re talking about why it may sometimes be best to do just the opposite and how it can help you find more Etsy shop success! So grab your favorite basket! Gather all of the eggs, and let’s get crazy in this latest blog post from The Jam.

All in your basket or not? 

Today we’re chatting through the topic of putting all your eggs in one basket. Should you? Shouldn’t you? Is there a balance between the two? To start things off, we want to share a quote with you. This quote inspired our team to tackle this particular topic.

The Quote

In Andrew Carnegie’s talk, entitled “The Road to Business Success,” he discussed his life as a successful businessperson. He gives this advice:

And here is the prime condition of success, the great secret—concentrate your energy, thought and capital exclusively upon the business in which you are engaged. Having begun on one line, resolve to fight it out on that line, to lead in it, adopt every improvement, have the best machinery, and know the most about it. The concerns which fail are those which have scattered their capital, which means that they have scattered their brains also.

They have investments in this, or that, or the other, here, there and everywhere. “Don’t put all your eggs in one basket” is all wrong. I tell you “put all your eggs in one basket, and then watch that basket.” Look around you and take notice; men who do that do not often fail. It is easy to watch and carry the one basket. It is trying to carry too many baskets that breaks most eggs in this country.” 

Breaking it down

Now, Carnegie was a  titan of industry in the late 1800s. But, this still pertains to our lives today! In fact, with the fast-paced world we now live in there are even more opportunities to be distracted and more reasons to be scattered than ever before. But, Carnegie still saw that to be an issue even in 1885 when he wrote this. It is incredible to think about distraction being an issue in the business world even before social media and modern technology. 

Bristling at the thought

When Lisa first read this quote, she said she really bristled at it because it’s so different from the advice she heard growing up. For Lisa, growing up through the recession and things of that nature, she was taught that is was dangerous to put all your eggs in one basket. In her life, the common theme seemed to be “Diversify, diversify, diversify!” So when she read the above quote all she could think was, “Are you kidding me?! Is this for real?”

But as we continued to dive a little deeper into the discussion, it became clear that there are times when putting all your eggs in one basket can actually be a good thing! For example, we see it in a lot of specialized fields like medicine. We might complain when our doctor decides we need to see a specialist and that specialist only does one thing. But, when you have an issue where you need a particular specialist that is amazing at what they do, the value of this person having taken the time to “put all their eggs in one basket” is huge!

It makes sense

So, in this example and in many others, specializing in something and becoming an expert can really make sense. Diversification might sound great, but there are downsides there too! If you’re really diversified, then when things get tough and you have yourself scattered all over the place with different projects and jobs, how can you know which one to give attention to? And if you have multiple things that need attention at the same time, that makes it even more complicated!

The other side of the coin

Ah but it wouldn’t be fun without playing the devil’s advocate! The other side of this is what happens when you’re focusing all on one thing and that one thing suddenly starts to tank? Then what? There is definitely evidence that shows a generalist knowledge of many things is very helpful! A lot of breakthroughs and disruptive innovations happen when someone from a different industry enters in and shakes things up. Why? Because they’re bringing in outside ideas that you wouldn’t see when you’re hyper-focused. So someone might be an expert in an industry, but oftentimes the experts are just incrementally improving upon what that industry has always done. 

Dabbling in a lot

Richie has a personality where he likes to dabble in a lot of different things. However, he says that he has to separate the fun and more personal side of doing a lot of different things from actually being productive. He says it’s way easier for him to be productive when he’s specialized in fewer things as opposed to trying to specialize in everything. Richie believes it’s best to pick something. For him, it’s best if he picks a system and works to become an expert in it, regardless of its flaws. For example, if he chooses to use Google Drive instead of Dropbox, he wants to work towards using it better than anyone has ever seen! 

A real-world example

Another great example of this happening in everyday life is with the apps on your phone. When you have an app on your phone it usually does one thing. Your text message app isn’t also for playing games. They all have a distinct thing that they’re trying to do the best. If an app shows up that’s trying to do a billion things, it’s probably not going to do any of them well. Finding and being a solution to one problem instead of trying to solve ALL the problems will always be good advice. 

The Etsy seller perspective

So let’s talk about your perspective as an Etsy seller. We often hear questions like these from sellers. “Should I break off and start another shop?” “Should I have three shops, each of them focusing on a different product?” And we know that even inside of one shop it can be easy to be pulled in several different directions. 

One thing at a time

Gordon said that when he read the quote that sparked this discussion, his mind immediately went to how many different directions you get pulled in as an Etsy seller. Pinterest, Instagram, marketing, Google ads, there are so. many. things. Being spread thin is something we hear a lot from Etsy sellers! We receive emails all the time asking if sellers can hire someone from our team to do their SEO for them because they’re swamped and need to focus on production. It’s true that if you’re a one-man or woman show, you have to throw everything at one task at a time and then keep moving on from there.

So what is the best use of your time? Honestly, if you’re starting a blog while also trying to start a separate website to sell your products while working on all the other things we mentioned…more than likely none of those things will get the attention they deserve or need in order to be successful. So, what you need to do is step back, take an honest assessment of where you are with your goals, choose one of your stepping stones to a goal, and get to work focusing on one thing at a time. 

So what’s our advice? Multiple shops or one? 

We say focus on the things that you can be best at. If you have extra time and it’s fun for you to focus on new things then do that in the extra time you have. Otherwise, we would be concerned that you’d get burned out by trying to create too complex of a system. Even if you like systems. You can still burn out if you try and do too much and make it too complicated. 

If you’re not having much success with one shop, we don’t think opening a second shop is going to help anything. If you are having success with one shop and are considering opening a second shop, it’s crucial for you to remember that another shop will add a ton more demands on your time. You really need to be mindful of this before jumping in. Too many demands have the potential to derail your first shop. Especially if you suddenly can not give it the time it needs.

New Conclusions

After this discussion, Lisa feels her conclusions are a little different than when she first read the quote. When she first read the quote she was equating being specialized with being closed off to everything else going on around you and not recognizing or reacting to the trends happening outside your basket. But she thinks that doesn’t have to be the case and that her original conclusion wasn’t what the author was getting at. Instead, she now reads the quote as a reminder to make sure you’re doing what’s in front of you well. And part of doing that is paying attention to what’s going on around you so you don’t drop your basket and bust all your eggs.

Final Thoughts

There truly is a balance. If you feel like you’re in a good place to start slowly putting eggs into a new basket, that’s awesome! What you don’t want is to have your eggs in so many baskets that none of them are getting the attention they need. Do what you’re good at. Stick with that until you feel solidly ready to branch out. But don’t branch out if you haven’t already gotten a good handle on what you’re currently doing. 

Also, remember that it’s never a good idea to branch out or start something new out of desperation. Starting multiple shops because you’re desperate for something to has the potential to snowball. Slow down, take a  breath, assess and be honest about the problems in your current shop and tackle those first. 

We know that you weren’t born selling on Etsy and more than likely your Etsy shop was you picking up a new basket and starting to put a few eggs in it. But you probably didn’t bet the entire farm on it. More than likely it was a slow process of figuring out what worked and what didn’t. So view starting any new shop like this. Start slow, dip your toes in the water, test what will and won’t work. But never start something new at the expense of a shop that is currently working for you. 

Let us hear from you!

We absolutely want to hear what your story and experiences are with all of this! Are you considering opening a new shop? Or maybe you’re just trying to improve your current shop and you’re torn between a ton of different things to accomplish this? Maybe you already tried too many things and had to scale back and you’ve found a good balance that’s working for you! Regardless, let us know in the comments below what is and isn’t working for you and how you got to where you are today.

Happy selling, everyone! 


Need help getting your products found on Etsy?

Improve your Etsy SEO with free Marmalead tools, designed to take your handmade business to the next level.

Get the FREE Tools

Subscribe to ♥ The Jam ♥ at:

11 replies on “All Your Eggs In One Basket”

I think it’s dangerous to put all your eggs in one ‘basket’ when you don’t own the basket. Etsy is a platform – it could go under tomorrow. For anyone selling just on Etsy, they are vulnerable. A seller needs to ‘diversify’ (if that’s what you want to call it) and spend some of their time on Pinterest, Facebook, etc., because that is getting the message out about their business – it’s part of running a business. It’s not ‘spreading yourself thinly’ if you divide up your time properly, and spend decent chunks of time doing each topic on each social media area.

I have a website, plus an Etsy shop. I wouldn’t have just one, now – they get different buyers visiting them, and have different SEO, and different looks, and different outcomes. That’s what being a micro business owner is about. Just having one ‘basket’ might be ‘simpler’, but not necessarily more profitable, or sensible, IMO.

I took a real quick look at your shop & the first thing I noticed is your titles are way too short. That limits who will see your items. Do an Etsy search for Thanksgiving wreaths & look at the titles other successful shops are using. Your titles and tags are what brings customers to your shop.
You only have 4 items for sale… list more to improve your sales. Make an Easter wreath, Mother’s day, 4th of July, Back to School, Christmas, etc.
Take more pics! Use all 10 photo slots and make sure your pictures are clear & showing the colors as accurately as possible.
Hope this helps
♡ Jewel

Given the way things are going with Etsy at the moment I don’t think this is a wise idea!

I agree 100% I like to reference a tool box instead of a basket. It’s all the tools you need to get one job done but each one serves a different purpose. It’s dangerous and naive to only have a hammer when you need a wrench. To that point you can look at your business as your basket. I totally agree don’t be a jack of all trades and focus yourself as a master in your nice but use the helpful tools necessary to safeguard your business and get the job done correctly.

Right now, I can’t afford to have a store outside of Etsy, and that worries me, because Etsy, it’s getting harder and harder.
I’m trying to get customers from other platforms as well. Etsy, unfortunately, is not giving enough confidence, and so, I try, to have my eggs in different baskets

Why would anyone choose to put all their eggs in someone else’s basket??? Etys can shut you down in a second without any explanation.

ok, so I thought this article is referring to creating multiple items in one shop, ie specializing in one type of thing or having different types of items….diversifying so to speak.

Thanks for the confusing article, still a bit lost but I think balance is the key. It’s different times we live in. I think being good at one thing these days will send you broke fast because of what you’ll have to pay to hire these specialists, experts and tech rip off artists instead of doing it yourself.
Most are trying to sell you ‘the dream’ life of running an online business if you pay them money. Whether it’s Facebook ads, Etsy ads or Google – none will help you if you don’t have the knowledge to use them no matter how much money you invest in their scams.

I tried focusing on one thing far too long, hoping to hire experts as needed. In the end you’re better off doing it all yourself. Become the expert in all areas of your own business. No one knows your business better than you!

I have a personal website and my Etsy shop. My sales are completely different. For whatever reason, certain products only sell on Etsy, and vise versa on my website, and I’ve learned to be okay with it. Being part of the e-commerce world, and with all the social media platforms out there, we have to be able to maintain a presence everywhere. However, I do agree that I don’t jump on to a new platform until I feel comfortable managing what I currently have. For example, I opened Etsy and Shopify. I worked on both at the same time. Once my Shopify was up and running all my attention went to Etsy to master SEO. Then, I focused on FB & Instagram to capture my curtain audience. I figured out Instagram shopping after 4 months, and I moved on to FB and getting more traffic through there. I have yet to open Pinterest because my attention is still with mastering Etsy SEO, or at least, learning to know what I’m doing, so I can try and have a balance everywhere. Yeah, sometimes I neglect one or the other but they all still provide exposure for my shop.

It’s so important question. But as for me it’s, so difficult. Every thing takes a lot of time. I make dolls, they are different and I understood that there is , I am not sure in my English, culture look and humor, that can be understoond differently. I tried ebay (I had sales but my price was very low), but then I opened my Etsy Shop ( I like it but key-words…) and now -live.muster.
I have Instagram but it doesn’t sell, more as a shop-window.

Leave a Reply